Witches Brew Coffee House Menu (Updated October 2025)
Welcome to Witches Brew Coffee House, a charming café nestled at 311 Hempstead Turnpike, West Hempstead, NY. This creative oasis invites food and coffee lovers alike with its unique ambiance and delightful offerings. The moment you step in, you’re greeted by a cozy interior that feels reminiscent of a Victorian home, brimming with antique touches and artistic decor.
The menu at Witches Brew is a thoughtfully curated selection that caters to a variety of tastes. Start your day with an aromatic Organic Almond or Organic Soy coffee for just $2.25, and pair it with their renowned Vegan Pastries. For those seeking something more substantial, the Chickpea Salad ($9.95) and flavorsome Greek Salad showcase fresh vegetables tossed in zesty dressings. Don’t miss out on sides like the savory Parmesan Fries or the innovative Sweet Chili Potato Squares, each priced at $6.95.
Customer reviews speak to Witches Brew's enchanting vibe and stellar service. Highlights include the phenomenal dirty chai and indulgent six cheese mac and cheese, which one guest fondly described as a late-night delight. Overall, this café delivers not just on flavor, but on an experience that leaves patrons eagerly returning for more. Whether you’re planning a date or a casual meet-up, Witches Brew Coffee House is a must-visit for a cozy and tasty retreat.
Appetizers
Goat Cheese Crostini
Warm crostini with black cherry marmalade, crumbled goat cheese & a sweet reduction sauce.
$9.25Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Homemade baked spinach & artichoke dip served with tortilla chips
$12.25Bruschetta
Fresh tomato, red onion, basil,olive oil & balsamic vinegar on a garlic crostini topped with grated parmesan.
$11.50Nachos
Nachos with black beans, olives, jalapeno & cheese topped with pico de gallo & guacamole crema
$9.95Mac & Cheese
Our famous baked mac & cheese made with 7 types of cheese.
$9.95Hummus & Pita (V)
House made organic hummus served with a warm pita.
$8.50Vegetable Spring Roll (V)
2 vegetable spring rolls served with sweet chili sauce
$7.25Steamed Vegetable Dumplings (V)
Steamed vegetable dumpling served with sweet chili & home made dumpling sauce.
$9.00Charred Hoisin Brussel Sprouts Served With Side Of Rice (V)
$7.95Salad
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce, grated parmesan cheese & croutons in a house made caesar dressing
$9.95Greek Salad
Romaine lettuce, cucumber, grape tomato, peppers, red onion, olives & feta cheese dressed in a red wine vinaigrette.
$9.95Beet Salad
Sliced roasted beets, hearts of palm, mango, dried cranberry, fresh spinach & arugula tossed in a orange vinaigrette topped with goat cheese.
$9.95Chickpea Salad (V)
Organic chickpeas, arugula, diced tomato, cucumber, peppers, red onion & fresh parsley tossed with lemon juice & olive oil.
$9.95Main Course
Pesto Gnocchi Or Tomato Gnocchi
Homemade creamy pesto or organic tomato sauce & shredded parmesan cheese.
$13.95Butternut Squash & Sage, Butter Gnocchi. (V)
Sauteed roasted butter nut squash with sage butter & gnocchi topped with toasted pumpkin seeds.
$13.95Trofie Alfredo & Mushroom
Cortecce pasta in a creamy alfredo mushroom sauce & shredded parmesan cheese.
$13.95Quesadilla
Bean and cheese quesadilla served with pico de gallo and sour cream.
$11.25Middle Eastern Platter (V)
Small plates of hummus, tabouli salad, four falafel balls and olives served with 2 warm pitas.
$14.95Coconut Curry (V)(Gfd)
Spicy thai red curry with tofu, mixed vegetables & rice noodles topped with fresh shredded cabbage & cilantro.
$13.95Pad Thai (V)
Sauteed vegetables, tofu & rice noodles tossed in a wok with our special tamarind sauce & topped with crushed peanuts.
$13.95Kale & Tofu Stir Fry (V) (Gf)
Organic kale organic tofu & organic jasmine rice stir fried together with organic tamari sauce ginger & garlic.
$15.95Mapo Tofu (V)
A spicy sichuan dish made with organic silken tofu & sichuan peppers served with organic jasmine rice.
$13.95Jamaican Jerk Tofu Steak (V)
Organic tofu with a spicy jerk sauce served with organic jasmine rice, organic sauteed kale & chickpeas.
$13.95Sides
Vegetable Of The Day (V)
$6.95French Fries (V)
$6.95Sweet Chili Potato Squares (V)
$6.95Sauteed Corn & Herbs
$6.95Sandwiches
Falafel Sandwich(V)
Homemade falafel with hummus,fresh chopped salad & tahini suace tahani sauce comes with potato salad or garden salad
$11.95Veggeie Burger
House made veggie burger topped with cheddar cheese,tomato,lettuce,onion & pickles dressed with a spicy with a spicy mayo on a ciabatta roll comes with potato salad or garden salad
$11.95Classic Italian
Fresh mozzarella,roasted peppers,red onion,tomato,basil & argula dressed with olive oil & balsamic vinegar on a ciabatta bread,comes with potato salad or garden salad
$11.95Is Real Lite(V)
Home made organic hummus,avocado,red onion,tomato & spinach on a whole wheat rustic bread.comes with potato salad or garden salad
$11.95Gyro Sandwich(V)
Sauteed seitan rolled in a flat bread with red onion ,sliced tomato & shredded lettuce dressed with a mint yogurt sauce comes with potato salad or garden salad
$12.00Chicken Caesar Wrap
Caesar salad with sliced mock chicken & parmesan cheese rolled in a warm spinach wrap.comes with potato salad or garden salad
$11.95Grilled Cheese
Traditional white bread with choice of swiss,cheddar or fresh mozzarell.comes with potato salad or garden salad
$10.50Tempeh Reuben (V)
Sliced tempeh coverd with hot sauerkraut on rye bread with house russian dressing.comes with potato salad or garden salad
$11.95Philly Seitan Cheese Steak
Seitan sauteed with onions & peppers topped with melted provolone cheese.comes with potato salad or garden salad
$11.95Coffee
Organic Milk
$2.25Organic Soy
$2.25Organic Almond
$2.25Cafe Aulait
Organic Coffee With Steamed Milk
$3.50Espresso Drink
Aloha Mocha
$6.00Amer Midnite
Autumn
Avesrednite
Banana Cream Pie
Bat
$6.00Black Cat
$6.00Black White
$6.00Black Widow
$6.00Black Magic
$6.00Blue Angel
$6.00Blue Moon
$6.00Broomstick
$6.00Cherrybomb
$6.00Chocolate Velvet
$6.00Crimsin
$6.00Dublin
Eskimo
$6.00Fire
$6.00Ghost
$6.00Gloomlifter
$6.00Gypsy
$6.00Halloween
$6.00Halo
$6.00Heaven
$6.00Inkwell
$6.00Bagels
Tofu Cream Cheese
$3.50Butter Cinn & Sugar
$5.00P.b. & Toasted Vegan Marshmallow
$6.25Vegan Mozzerella And Peppers
$6.25P.b. & Jelly
$5.001 Scoop
Sorbet
$4.75Tofutti
$4.75Others
1/2 Coffee
$4.001/2 Cocoa
$4.00Hot Cocoa
$3.50Blood Shot
Small organic coffee with espresso
$3.75Michaels Racehorse
16-oz.latte
$7.95Allniter
Large organic coffee with double espresso
$4.75Espresso
Organic double
$3.75Macchiato
4oz. Organic double espresso with foam
$4.00Cappuccino
$4.50Mochaccino
$5.25Cafe Latte
$4.50Americano
2/3 hot water with organic double espresso
$3.75Pastry
$4.50Brownie
$4.75Cinn Bunn
$5.75Smores
$4.50Foccacia
Fresh baked bread
$5.50King Kong
Banana chocolate marshmallow syrup
Eprechaun
Irish creme hazelnut
Midnite
Chocolate marshmallow syrup
Moon
Marshmallow syrup banana p-b
Nitemare
Caramel p-b chocolate
October
Marshmallow syrup caramel p-b
P B Jelly
Grape p-b
Pink Angel
Strawberry vanilla
Reddeath
Cherry chocolate
Revolution
Hazelnut chocolate caramel
Snowflake
Vanilla mint marshmallow syrup
Solstice
Maple & english toffee
Sorrow
Chocolate & cupcake
Southern Revolution
Praline caramel chocolate
Sugardaddy
Caramel praline
Sweetness
Caramel almond roca
The Ciash
English toffee caramel
Tyranny
Coconut chocolate caramel
Vagabond
Caramel coconut
Vamp
Raspberry chocolate
Yoodoo
French vanilla marshmallow syrup
White Angel
Coconut vanilla
Winter
Marshmallow syrup vanilla
Witch Doctor
Vanilla p-b hazelnut
Wish
Strawberry & cupcake
Zombie
Tiramisu chocolate
Extra Menu Picks
- Shibuya Menu 4774 Park Granada, Calabasas, CA 91302, United States
- JakeaBob's Bay Menu 525 Front St, Union Beach, NJ 07735, United States
- King Buffet Menu 1375 N Western Ave, Los Angeles, CA 90027, United States
- Happy Lamb Hot Pot Mountain View Menu 102 Castro St, Mountain View, CA 94041, United States
- Delicious Dim Sum Menu 752 Jackson St, San Francisco, CA 94133, United States
- Phở 87 Menu 1019 N Broadway, Los Angeles, CA 90012, United States
- Corner Cottage Menu 310 S Victory Blvd, Burbank, CA 91502, United States
- Absolute Bagels Menu 2788 Broadway, New York, NY 10025, United States
- Petrillo's Pizza Menu 833 E Valley Blvd, San Gabriel, CA 91776, United States
- Phởholic Menu 14932 Bushard St, Westminster, CA 92683, United States